Appaloosa Saloon is widely praised for its cozy and welcoming atmosphere, complemented by friendly and efficient service. Guests frequently highlight the delicious food, noting its consistent quality and accommodating nature, including attentiveness to special dietary needs such as gluten-free options. The restaurant is appreciated for its relaxed and uncomplicated setting, making it ideal for small group gatherings and casual dining. While the overall experience is described as excellent, a few reviews mention minor concerns such as occasional saltiness in some dishes and occasional noise in the environment. Nevertheless, the professionalism and kindness of the staff contribute positively to the dining experience, encouraging repeat visits.